Our Staff & Elders

Please feel free to contact any of our staff with concerns or questions by clicking on their photos. We are eager to help.

Peter Bartuska -Transitional pastor

Peter Bartuska “Pastor Peter", was born in Camden, N.J., but calls Boca Raton his Hometown. He was married to his wife, Terri, for just a couple of months shy of 36 years when Terri died from a rare form of liver cancer. He has three children: Taylor (m. Guthrie), Andrew (m. Anna) and Shelby (m. Nate & two grandchildren; Tatum and Easton).  

Pastor Peter received his Bachelor’s degree in Christian Education/Psychology from Taylor University and his Master of Divinity Degree from Westminster Theological Seminary and Reformed Theological Seminary.

He has been working in pastoral ministry since 1990. He was the Youth Director at Howell Branch Fellowship in Winter Park, Florida, Church Planting Intern at Spanish River Church; started a Church and Pastored that same church in Danville, Kentucky; Pastor of Treasure Coast Presbyterian Church, and most recently Pastor of Christ Community Church in Wellington, Florida, where he finished in May 2025. He also served as the Stated Clerk of the Gulfstream Presbytery from 2006 to 2014.  Peter is serving as our Transitional Pastor and will be living and working with us in Puerto Rico, while we work towards hiring our next Lead Pastor.

Kyle Culbertson - Associate Pastor

An Ohio native, Kyle Culbertson brings a vibrant passion for connecting people to our church community. Having previously come to Puerto Rico to play soccer, God brought Kyle back to the island in 2022 to embrace a new journey serving at Trinity. What began as an athletic opportunity became a clear calling to ministry and community building.

Married to Morgan, Kyle cherishes family life with his two children, Ellie Joy and Bennett Gabriel. He tries not to take himself too seriously and loves fostering meaningful connections within our church family. His favorite thing about Trinity is the opportunity to welcome newcomers and guide them toward deeper engagement with Christ and His Church, helping them move from simply attending to truly belonging.

Kyle has a deep desire to see more healthy, gospel-centered churches planted, particularly in places where vibrant biblical witness is greatly needed. He is committed to the broader church planting movement as a vital expression of Christ’s mission in the world and longs to see communities transformed through faithful preaching, discipleship, and hospitality.

Outside of ministry, Kyle enjoys drinking good coffee, playing sports, and trying to keep up with his energetic kids. Nothing quite compares to a well-made latte and an afternoon spent with family.

Natalia M Martínez E - Director of Worship & Operations

Natalia was born and raised in Puerto Rico and in the Gospel. By the Lord’s grace, her love for Christ and His Church has only deepened over the years. She earned her undergraduate degree in History of the Americas from the University of Puerto Rico and her Master of Divinity from Covenant Theological Seminary.

Natalia serves as Director of Worship & Operations, leading the music ministry and overseeing the operational life of the church.

She is passionate about cultivating Christ-centered, reverent, and congregational worship that is both theologically rich and deeply participatory.

In her operations role, she supports the administrative and logistical systems that help the church function with clarity, stewardship, and integrity.

She has a deep love for Puerto Rico and is committed to long-term ministry on the island, desiring to see healthy, gospel-centered churches flourish for generations.

In addition to her work at Trinity, she serves as an officer in the United States Army Reserve, a commitment that has shaped her leadership and discipline.

Outside of church life, Natalia enjoys going to the movies, playing music with friends, and savoring mofongo with a cold Malta India.

JenNIfer Jones - Office manager

Jennifer serves as the Office Manager and oversees the daily administrative operations of the church. With a strong business background and a passion for the church, she is dedicated to supporting the leadership team and ensuring smooth communication throughout the church community.

Jennifer is especially passionate about bringing people together and helping create a welcoming environment where relationships can grow and ministry can thrive.

Outside of her role at the church, Jennifer enjoys being with her family, exploring the island and connecting with friends.

Our Elders

GERSON SANTOS - Director of OUTREACH & Missions

Gerson serves with a deep passion for service, community outreach, and the advancement of Christ’s Kingdom through leading others to church planting. He was part of the team that helped plant Trinity Church in 2014, and his heart continues to beat for the planting and strengthening of healthy, gospel-centered churches. As part of his preparation, he received church planting training in Thailand, where he was certified as a Trainer with Dynamic Church Planting International (DCPI). An experience that broadened his vision for cross-cultural ministry and deepened his commitment to the global mission of God.

He holds a Bachelor’s degree in Psychology from Universidad Interamericana de Puerto Rico and a Master in Theological Studies from Southern Baptist Theological Seminary.

In addition to his local ministry, as a Ruling Elder of the SFP, Gerson serves on the Missions Committee of the South Florida Presbytery, contributing to the advancement of church planting and global missions beyond Puerto Rico.

Gerson is married to Wendolyn Ortega (Gwen), and together they share the joy of raising Violeta, a dedicated swimmer.

He desires for others to see not only the natural beauty of the island, but the spiritual beauty of Christ at work in its communities.

Hobbies: Backpacking (especially cultural immersion experiences), music, and the arts in general. And nothing compares to starting the day with a morning swim in the sea.